The best software for a new staffing agency

A new staffing agency needs four tools on day one: an ATS and CRM for candidates and clients, accounting software, e-signature and a job board account. A temp firm adds payroll, time capture and background checks before its first temp starts. Most of it is monthly, from about $27 for accounting.

By Brett Iredale, Founder and CEO of Lovelio. Updated

Buy software by the job it does, in the order you need it. A direct hire agency sells introductions, so it needs a place to keep people and clients, a way to sign terms and a way to send invoices. A temporary staffing firm employs its temps, so it also needs payroll, a record of hours and the checks clients ask for. No single product does all of it well. The usual setup is an ATS and CRM for the recruiting work and a payroll tool for the employer work, joined by a link between them.

Your software, job by job

This is the full set for a US staffing agency, with the point at which each one starts to pay for itself.

CategoryWhat it doesWhen you need it
AccountingInvoices, bank feeds, expenses and the numbers your accountant files fromDay one
ATS and CRMCandidates, clients, jobs, submissions and placements in one placeDay one
E-signatureSigned terms with clients and signed documents from candidatesDay one
Job boardsPosts your jobs where candidates searchYour first open job
Payroll, or a payroll funderPays temps, withholds and files payroll taxesBefore your first temp starts
Time captureRecords hours each day and week, gets them approved by the clientBefore your first temp starts
Background checksRuns criminal, employment and other checks with FCRA consentWhen a client or role asks for it
Employment eligibilityForm I-9 for every hire, E-Verify where you choose or mustBefore your first temp starts

ATS and CRM: where the recruiting happens

Your ATS and CRM holds every candidate, client and job, and shows where each candidate sits with each client. It is the tool you open first every morning, so pick it for speed and how little setup it needs.

What to look for:

  • Jobs that belong to a client, so every placement traces back to who pays you.
  • Resume reading that fills the candidate record for you.
  • Submissions to clients from inside the system, with the client's answer coming back to the pipeline.
  • Contract placements that hold the pay rate, charge rate and margin.
  • An open API, so a payroll or timesheet partner can read the placement.
  • No setup fee, no long contract, and moving your data in done for you.

Where Lovelio fits

Lovelio is an ATS and CRM for agencies. It fills that one slot. New agencies on Lovelio Launch run their first 2 months free, and every plan includes unlimited users.

You create a job by describing it, and every job belongs to a client. Ads go to your public job board and to Indeed through a feed that is on from the start. The Chrome extension turns a job into a LinkedIn search and saves the people you pick. A resume upload fills the candidate record. You send candidates to clients through a portal link, and each client verdict moves the pipeline.

For temps and contractors, a placement records the charge rate, pay rate, margin and expected gross profit. Rate cards carry cost lines such as a 401(k) contribution, payroll tax or insurance, so the margin you see is the real one. The Contractors page shows end dates and each contractor's Documents, such as right to work and licenses.

Lovelio does not run timesheets or payroll. Those run in your payroll tool. A connected timesheet or payroll partner reads each placement through the API: the workplace, timesheet approvers, rates and payment terms. Lovelio never stores a tax number or bank details.

Payroll and back office

A temp firm is the employer of record, so it runs payroll every pay period. Payroll software pays temps, withholds income tax, pays the employer share of Social Security and Medicare, deposits payroll taxes on the IRS schedule and files Form 941 every quarter.

You have two ways to buy it. A payroll provider runs payroll and you fund it from your own cash. A payroll funder advances most of each client invoice and often runs payroll, tax filings and client invoicing as part of the service. In year one, while you are short of cash, the funder route often replaces two or three tools at once.

What to look for:

  • Weekly pay runs, since temps are often paid weekly.
  • Multi-state payroll, if you place temps across state lines.
  • Workers' compensation reporting by job class.
  • Client invoicing built from approved hours, so the bill matches the pay.
  • A link to your ATS, so a new placement does not have to be typed in twice.

Time capture

Every hour a non-exempt temp works must be on record. The Department of Labor requires employers to keep hours worked each day and each workweek, payroll records for 3 years and time cards for 2 years.

Time capture is often part of your payroll tool or funder. Look for client approval inside the app, a mobile clock-in for temps on site, and an export your payroll reads without retyping.

Accounting

Accounting software sends invoices, matches bank payments and gives your accountant clean books at tax time. Xero and QuickBooks are two well-known choices for small businesses. Xero's US plans list at $27, $59 and $97 a month.

A direct hire agency invoices from here. Lovelio connects to Xero and turns each permanent placement into a draft invoice, which you approve and send from Xero. Contract and temp invoices come from approved timesheets in your payroll system.

E-signature

You need signed terms before you send a client a candidate, and signed documents from temps before they start. Under the federal ESIGN Act a signature or contract cannot be denied legal effect only because it is electronic. Many ATS, payroll and onboarding tools include e-signature, so check what you already have before buying a separate tool.

Background checks

Background checks come from a consumer reporting agency, so the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies. Checkr, for example, lists checks at $29.99, $59.99 and $94.99 a report, before pass-through fees such as court costs. Any provider you choose should handle these steps for you:

  • Before the check: a stand-alone written disclosure and the candidate's written permission.
  • Before you decide against someone: a notice with a copy of the report and the FTC summary of rights.
  • After the decision: an adverse action notice.

Job boards

Indeed lets you post many jobs free and pay only to sponsor the ones that need more reach. It bills sponsored jobs on the 1st of each month or when spend reaches $500. Jobs that come in from an ATS feed may be shown as sponsored only, so check how your feed is treated before you rely on free reach. Add paid boards one role at a time, when a free post is not bringing the right people.

Form I-9 and E-Verify

Every US employer completes Form I-9 for every person it hires, and a temp firm hires every temp. Your payroll or onboarding tool should collect it. E-Verify is a free federal online service that checks employment eligibility against government records.

What to buy on day one, and what can wait

A direct hire agency needs four things on day one: an ATS and CRM, accounting, e-signature and a free job board account. Background checks wait until a client asks.

A temp firm needs those four plus payroll, time capture and Form I-9 before the first temp works a shift. Background checks usually come at the same time, because most clients ask for them. Buy each on a monthly plan with no long contract until you know your volume.

Questions

What software does a staffing agency need?

An ATS and CRM, accounting software, e-signature and a job board account. A temp or contract firm also needs payroll, time capture, background checks and a way to complete Form I-9 for every hire.

Does an ATS run payroll for temps?

Usually not. Payroll and timesheets run in a payroll tool or through a payroll funder. The ATS holds the placement, its pay and charge rates, and passes them to payroll through a link.

What is the cheapest software setup for a new staffing agency?

Lovelio Launch gives new agencies their first 2 months of the ATS and CRM free. Add accounting from $27 a month on Xero's US plans, free job posts on Indeed, and e-signature from a tool you already have. Temps add payroll and checks.

Do I need background check software?

Only when a client or role asks for checks, which is common for temp work. The provider must follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act: written disclosure, the candidate's permission, and notices before and after any decision based on the report.

Is an electronic signature legal on a staffing agreement?

Yes. The federal ESIGN Act says a signature or contract cannot be denied legal effect only because it is electronic.

Put your ATS and CRM in place today

Apply for Lovelio Launch and run your first 2 months free.